What’s The Difference Between TMS & ECT?

What’s The Difference Between TMS & ECT?

The Albany Clinic • June 2, 2023

Mental health conditions can be challenging to treat, and traditional therapy, medication, or lifestyle changes may not always be enough to provide relief. For patients with treatment-resistant depression, two alternative treatments are TMS and ECT. Many people confuse the two, but they are very different methods of treatment.

In this article, we will explore the differences between TMS and ECT and examine their effectiveness, side effects, and who can benefit from each treatment.

Understanding TMS & ECT

Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) are two treatments used to alleviate symptoms of depression and other mental health conditions. While both treatments are effective, they differ in their approach and level of invasiveness.

What Is TMS?

TMS is a non-invasive treatment that uses magnetic fields to stimulate nerve cells in the brain. This stimulation can help alleviate symptoms of depression and other mental health conditions.

During a TMS session, the patient sits in a comfortable chair while a technician holds a coil over their head. The coil sends magnetic pulses to the brain, which stimulates nerve cells and improves mood. TMS treatments are typically performed in an outpatient setting and do not require anesthesia or sedation.

One of the benefits of TMS is that it is a relatively safe and painless procedure. Patients can return to their normal activities immediately after the treatment, and there are typically no side effects. Additionally, TMS can be used in conjunction with other treatments, such as medication and therapy, to enhance their effectiveness.

What Is ECT?

ECT is a more invasive treatment that uses electric currents to trigger a seizure in the brain. The seizure can help alleviate symptoms of depression and other mental health conditions.

During an ECT session, the patient is given an anesthetic and a muscle relaxant to prevent them from convulsing. Then, electrodes are attached to their scalp, and an electrical current is passed through the brain to induce a seizure. ECT treatments are typically done in an outpatient setting, but require sedation or anesthesia.

ECT is generally reserved for patients who have not responded to other treatments, such as medication and therapy. It can be an effective treatment for severe depression, bipolar disorder, and other mental health conditions. However, ECT is more invasive than TMS and can have more side effects, such as memory loss and confusion. Patients may also experience headaches, muscle aches, and nausea after the treatment.

Which Treatment Is Right For You?

If you are struggling with depression or another mental health condition, it is vital to talk to your doctor about your treatment options. TMS and ECT are just two of the many treatments available, and your doctor can help you determine which one is right for you. Factors such as the severity of your symptoms, your medical history, and your personal preferences will all be taken into account when deciding on a treatment plan.

Remember, seeking treatment is an important step towards improving your mental health and overall well-being. With the right treatment and support, it is possible to manage your symptoms and lead a fulfilling life.

The Science Behind TMS & ECT

How TMS Works

When the magnetic pulses from TMS pass through the brain, they stimulate the nerve cells in the prefrontal cortex. This area of the brain is responsible for mood regulation, and by stimulating it, TMS can improve symptoms of depression and other mental health conditions. TMS treatments typically last 20-30 minutes and are performed five days a week for four to six weeks.

During a TMS session, the patient sits in a chair and a magnetic coil is placed on their scalp. The magnetic pulses are painless and do not require anesthesia. Some patients may experience a tapping or knocking sensation on their scalp during the treatment, but this is generally well-tolerated.

TMS is a relatively new treatment, having been approved by the FDA in 2008. It is considered a safe and effective treatment option for patients who have not responded well to other treatments, such as medication and therapy.

How ECT Works

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) has been used to treat mental illness for over 80 years. During an ECT session, an electric current is passed through the brain, triggering a seizure. This seizure has been linked to the release of chemicals in the brain that can improve mood. However, the exact mechanism of action is not well understood.

ECT treatments are usually given two to three times per week, for a total of six to twelve treatments, depending on the patient’s response. During the treatment, the patient is given anesthesia and a muscle relaxant to prevent injury during the seizure.

While ECT has a reputation for being a harsh and outdated treatment, it is still used today in cases where other treatments have not been effective. It is generally reserved for patients with severe depression or other mental health conditions who are at risk of harm to themselves or others.

Despite its effectiveness, ECT does have some potential side effects, such as memory loss, confusion, and headaches. However, these side effects are usually temporary and can be managed with medication and therapy.

Comparing TMS & ECT

Effectiveness In Treating Mental Health Conditions

Both TMS and ECT have been shown to be effective in treating depression and other mental health conditions. TMS has been FDA-approved since 2008 and has been shown to be effective in approximately 60% of patients. ECT has been in use since the 1930s and has been shown to be effective in approximately 70% of patients. However, ECT is typically reserved for patients with more severe and treatment-resistant depression.

It is crucial to note that the effectiveness of these treatments may vary depending on the individual patient and their specific mental health condition. Some patients may respond better to TMS, while others may respond better to ECT. It is essential for patients to work closely with their healthcare provider to determine the best treatment option for their individual needs.

Side Effects & Risks

TMS is a non-invasive treatment and does not have many reported side effects. Some patients may experience headaches or mild discomfort at the site of the magnetic pulses. These side effects are typically mild and go away shortly after the treatment is completed.

ECT, on the other hand, is a more invasive treatment and has more associated risks. Patients may experience confusion, memory loss, or headaches after an ECT treatment. These side effects are typically short-term and go away within a few hours to a few days after the treatment is completed. However, in rare cases, patients may experience more serious side effects, such as heart problems or seizures.

It is important for patients to discuss the potential side effects and risks of each treatment option with their healthcare provider before making a decision.

Duration & Frequency Of Treatments

TMS treatments last approximately 20-30 minutes, and patients typically require five treatments per week for four to six weeks. This treatment schedule allows patients to continue with their daily activities and does not require any downtime or recovery time.

ECT treatments last longer, approximately 10-20 minutes, but patients may require more treatments. In total, patients usually receive six to twelve ECT treatments, two to three times per week. This treatment schedule may require patients to take time off from work or other daily activities to recover from the treatment.

It is critical for patients to consider the duration and frequency of treatments when choosing between TMS and ECT. TMS may be a more convenient option for patients who have busy schedules or who do not want to take time off from work or other daily activities. ECT may be a better option for patients who require more intensive treatment or who have not responded well to other treatment options.

Who Can Benefit From TMS & ECT?

Candidates For TMS

TMS is a non-invasive procedure that uses magnetic fields to stimulate nerve cells in the brain. It is typically recommended for patients with treatment-resistant depression or those who cannot tolerate medication. TMS has been shown to be effective in treating depression, anxiety, and other mood disorders.

During a TMS session , the patient sits in a comfortable chair while a magnetic coil is placed on their head. The coil delivers magnetic pulses to specific areas of the brain that are responsible for regulating mood. The treatment is painless and does not require any anesthesia.

Patients with metal implants in the head or neck should not undergo TMS treatments. Additionally, TMS may not be suitable for patients with a history of seizures or other neurological conditions.

Candidates For ECT

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a more invasive treatment that involves passing electrical currents through the brain to trigger a seizure. ECT is typically recommended for patients with severe, treatment-resistant depression, or those who are suicidal.

ECT has been shown to be effective in treating a variety of mental health conditions, including depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia. However, it is usually considered a last resort treatment due to its potential side effects.

During an ECT session, the patient is given anesthesia and a muscle relaxant to prevent injury during the seizure. The electrical currents are delivered through electrodes placed on the scalp. The treatment usually takes less than 30 minutes.

Patients with a history of heart problems, seizures, or other medical conditions may not be able to undergo ECT treatments. Additionally, ECT can cause side effects such as confusion, memory loss, and headaches.

The Future Of TMS & ECT

Advances In TMS Technology

Currently, researchers are investigating new ways to deliver TMS treatments, such as using multiple coils at once to stimulate multiple areas of the brain. These advances may increase the effectiveness and efficiency of TMS treatments.

Advances In ECT Technology

Newer ECT machines use lower levels of electricity, which may reduce the risk of side effects such as memory loss. There is also research being done to combine ECT with other treatments, such as medication or psychotherapy.

Conclusion

At The Albany Clinic , we understand the importance of finding the right treatment for individuals with treatment-resistant depression and other mental health conditions. TMS and ECT are two valuable options that offer distinct benefits and risks.

If you or someone you know is considering these treatments, we encourage you to schedule a consultation with our experienced team. We will assess your unique needs and help you make an informed decision about the most suitable treatment option for you. Take the next step towards finding relief and improving your mental well-being by reaching out to The Albany Clinic today. Your journey to a better quality of life starts here.

If you are interested in learning more about ketamine for TMS therapy treatment in Carbondale, IL, contact the Albany Clinic and request your consultation today.

Book Your Free Initial Consultation
By Matt Rodriguez March 3, 2025
Struggling with a social anxiety disorder (SAD) can feel isolating and overwhelming, especially when other medications haven’t proved effective. However, ketamine therapy offers a promising path forward, showing fast and significant relief from SAD symptoms. At The Albany Clinic in Albany, New York, we provide customized ketamine treatment plans designed to empower patients to overcome the challenges of SAD. Read on to explore the science and benefits of this transformative approach. Understanding Social Anxiety Disorder Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD), often referred to as social phobia, is a chronic mental health condition characterized by extreme fear and discomfort in social situations. While occasional nervousness in social settings is normal, social anxiety disorder is more persistent and can significantly disrupt daily life, relationships, and career opportunities. According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) , 7.1% of the U.S. population experiences social anxiety disorder annually. Recognizing the Symptoms of SAD The symptoms of social anxiety disorder can be grouped into three categories: emotional, behavioral, and physical. Emotional Symptoms: Intense fear of social interactions, particularly with strangers. Persistent worry about being judged or negatively evaluated. Excessive anxiety about upcoming social events, often for weeks in advance. Overwhelming self-consciousness in social environments. Behavioral Symptoms: Avoidance of social situations. Skipping school, work, or events to avoid social interaction. Relying on alcohol or other substances to ease anxiety in social settings. Physical Symptoms: Sweating, trembling, dry mouth, or muscle tension. Panic attacks in extreme cases. At The Albany Clinic, we understand the debilitating impact of these symptoms and offer ketamine therapy as a groundbreaking approach to address SAD. Our compassionate team is dedicated to creating personalized treatment plans tailored to each patient’s unique needs. How Ketamine Therapy Helps Treat Social Anxiety Ketamine has emerged as a promising treatment for social anxiety disorder due to its unique mechanism of action. Unlike traditional treatments, ketamine interacts with NMDA receptors in the brain, enhancing neuroplasticity —the brain’s ability to form new neural connections. This process can help improve brain function in areas related to stress and emotional regulation, potentially improving symptoms of SAD. Brain scanning experiments show ketamine alters connectivity in a brain region called the anterior insular cortex , which is thought to play a key role in social emotions. Studies suggest that this region may become dysfunctional in SAD, but ketamine could help restore its normal function and reduce SAD symptoms. Ketamine also lowers the activity of the amygdala , a brain region linked to fear and the body’s stress response. In people with anxiety, the amygdala is often overactive. Ketamine may help by calming this overactivity and reducing feelings of fear. Benefits of Ketamine for SAD Ketamine offers several benefits for treating SAD . One of its most significant advantages is its rapid action , often providing relief within hours, compared to the weeks or months traditional antidepressants can take. Additionally, ketamine has shown sustained effects , with a single dose sometimes improving symptoms for days or even weeks. Whereas common anti-anxiety medications, such as antidepressants, are used every day, ketamine is used more infrequently . A typical dosing regime involves twice-weekly sessions for the first four weeks, with more spaced-out sessions thereafter. This prevents people from developing tolerance to the drug, so they don’t experience withdrawal symptoms once they stop taking medication. However, ketamine does have an abuse potential , and ketamine addiction can lead to severe health consequences. For this reason, it’s essential to use ketamine in carefully controlled clinical environments under medical supervision, such as our clinic in Albany. Typical anti-anxiety medication is also associated with side effects that affect daily function, such as weight gain or sexual dysfunction . Ketamine, on the other hand, has mild side effects that generally wear off once the drug is cleared from the system. These include: Dizziness Decreased heart rate and blood pressure Drowsiness Nausea Research Supporting Ketamine for Social Anxiety A clinical trial from Yale University found ketamine infusions significantly decreased measures of social phobia in anxiety patients, compared to a placebo drug. The difference in improvement was significant from two days post-treatment and lasted up to the two-week follow-up. In another study from the University of Otago, patients with both generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) and SAD had significantly improved symptoms two weeks following ketamine treatment. These patients had been previously non-responsive to other therapies. Is Ketamine Therapy Right for You? Ketamine therapy is not suitable for everyone, but it can be highly effective for those who have not found relief with traditional treatments. You may be a good candidate if: You have been diagnosed with SAD, or another severe form of anxiety Conventional medications or therapies have not provided sufficient relief You are seeking a treatment with faster results However, ketamine therapy may not be recommended if you have: A current or past history of substance abuse You have specific liver or heart conditions You have a history of psychosis At The Albany Clinic, our experienced providers will carefully evaluate your medical history to determine if ketamine therapy is the best option for you. Building a Social Anxiety Treatment Plan at The Albany Clinic Step 1: Initial Consultation Your journey begins with a complimentary consultation to discuss whether ketamine therapy is suitable for you. During this session, our team will answer your questions, assess your mental health history, and develop a personalized treatment plan aligned with your recovery goals. Step 2: Ketamine Infusion Therapy Infusion sessions at The Albany Clinic are conducted in a modern , calming environment designed to put you at ease. Patients are provided with headphones , eye masks , and curated music playlists , though you are welcome to bring your own music if preferred. Each infusion session lasts about 40 minutes , during which time you’ll receive an injection of ketamine directly into the bloodstream through a vein. A dedicated provider will be present throughout your session to monitor your safety and comfort. Step 3: Lifestyle Adjustments and Aftercare Most patients require a series of treatments for optimal results. However, successful management of social anxiety extends beyond therapy sessions. Our team offers tailored aftercare guidance to help you integrate the positive effects of ketamine therapy into your daily life, promoting long-term well-being.  Interested? If you are struggling with social anxiety disorder and looking for an innovative approach to enhance your mental health, The Albany Clinic in Albany, NY, offers expert-led ketamine therapy designed to meet your needs. Our compassionate team is committed to providing evidence-based treatment plans to help you regain control and live a fulfilling life. To find out if ketamine therapy is the right choice for you, schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our specialists today.
By Kimberly Mercille January 22, 2025
In this article, we’ll explore how TMS and antidepressants work, compare their effectiveness, safety, and costs, and help you determine which treatment might be right for you. Whether you’re considering TMS, antidepressants, or a combination of both, understanding your options can empower you to make an informed decision about your mental health journey.
A woman is covering her ears while a group of people point at her.
By The Albany Clinic December 16, 2024
This blog will help you better understand social anxiety disorder and the various treatments that can help you or a loved one feel great again.
Share by: